by
yaelstiel answers to a viwer
Hey Nonny, first I am sorry you feel so disappointed about that. I , however, see it differently. I’d love to explain:
First, I really trust Jeremy Carver. I do. And I know for fact he doesn’t bend to any suggestion made by the actors. but, they are working together and hearing them out and considering the way they perceive the character is important and good. (Remember Jensen’s original script in the crypt scene in 8x17? I am glad he changed it from love to need, it was really much more Dean.)
I also don’t think that the actor own the character, but I do believe he has some deeper view, I don’t have to agree, and it won’t ruin the show for me as long as he is playing good (and , they definitely are)
Now about Jared’s change, I think it was a good one. I don’t, for one second, think it erased Sam’s development.
Dean was dying in his arms, literally dying, and in the most horrible way, defeated, ridiculous, bloody. Sam needed Dean to save all his energy now.
So when Dean asks ‘what happened to you being okay with this?’ , Sam could’ve answer ‘that wasn’t what I meant back there….’ but then imagine Dean, in his last moments starting to think what Sam meant if not that? Because that was how Dean saw it, he thought ‘I wouldn’t’ means ’I wouldn’t save you if you were dying’ while we all know Sam meant ‘I wouldn’t let anyone possess you no matter what.I wouldn’t’
So at this very moment, Sam can be right and tell Dean ‘no, that wasn’t what I meant’ , and hope to god he will be able to explain that to Dean and make Dean understand he loves him and is not okay with him dying- before he is dead.
Or he can be smart, and loving, and to understand that in that moment, he knows he might not have one more second with his brother, so he says ‘I lied’ , because this is the simplest way to tell Dean ’ I love you still. I don’t want you dead’. the simplest and the one that Dean will be alive enough to hear this.
Imagine Sam starts to explain, and Dean dying in the middle of it, thinking still that Sam wouldn’t save him? that is the most horrible scene I can imagine.
So on that specific change, I love that. From the beginning and with every single ask or discussion I love it even more.
This is Sam being the loving brother he is, doing the best thing he can at this awful moment. Still Sam, still growing, still wouldn’t do the same in the same circumstances…
I hope my answer helped you understand and be less upset.
First, I really trust Jeremy Carver. I do. And I know for fact he doesn’t bend to any suggestion made by the actors. but, they are working together and hearing them out and considering the way they perceive the character is important and good. (Remember Jensen’s original script in the crypt scene in 8x17? I am glad he changed it from love to need, it was really much more Dean.)
I also don’t think that the actor own the character, but I do believe he has some deeper view, I don’t have to agree, and it won’t ruin the show for me as long as he is playing good (and , they definitely are)
Now about Jared’s change, I think it was a good one. I don’t, for one second, think it erased Sam’s development.
Dean was dying in his arms, literally dying, and in the most horrible way, defeated, ridiculous, bloody. Sam needed Dean to save all his energy now.
So when Dean asks ‘what happened to you being okay with this?’ , Sam could’ve answer ‘that wasn’t what I meant back there….’ but then imagine Dean, in his last moments starting to think what Sam meant if not that? Because that was how Dean saw it, he thought ‘I wouldn’t’ means ’I wouldn’t save you if you were dying’ while we all know Sam meant ‘I wouldn’t let anyone possess you no matter what.I wouldn’t’
So at this very moment, Sam can be right and tell Dean ‘no, that wasn’t what I meant’ , and hope to god he will be able to explain that to Dean and make Dean understand he loves him and is not okay with him dying- before he is dead.
Or he can be smart, and loving, and to understand that in that moment, he knows he might not have one more second with his brother, so he says ‘I lied’ , because this is the simplest way to tell Dean ’ I love you still. I don’t want you dead’. the simplest and the one that Dean will be alive enough to hear this.
Imagine Sam starts to explain, and Dean dying in the middle of it, thinking still that Sam wouldn’t save him? that is the most horrible scene I can imagine.
So on that specific change, I love that. From the beginning and with every single ask or discussion I love it even more.
This is Sam being the loving brother he is, doing the best thing he can at this awful moment. Still Sam, still growing, still wouldn’t do the same in the same circumstances…
I hope my answer helped you understand and be less upset.
Keine Kommentare:
Kommentar veröffentlichen